One reason for this surprising neglect is the historical prominence of the dichotomy between. Structure and substance in arti cialphonology learning. Hlerarchles in concept attalnmen in the selectlon mode. Students in lesotho secondary schools were given a test on the logical connectives and, or, and ifthen in either english or sesotho. In 2 experiments, 78 and 48 undergraduates, respectively, solved several problems in which the object was to find the correct conceptual rule out of 4 rules conjunctive, disjunctive, conditional, or biconditional for sorting of geometrical designs. The simplicity principle in human concept learning citeseerx. The purpose of this study was to determine the effect of increasing the number of irrelevant dimensions ir for 10 concept types with two types of start cards under conditions of the selection mode. Some, according to neisser and weene 1962, are structurally more complex than others. Ulric neisser and paul weene, in a paper entitled a note on human recognition of handprinted characters information and control 3, 2 1960 report results of a series of tests that they conducted to determine the accuracy of human observers when reading handwritten script.
Ucberkeley phonetic precursors and 2014 may 31 sat. A synthesis of mentalarchitecture, randomwalk, and decisionbound approaches mario fific. Garner 1962 argued that the difficulty of the concepts. Four decades ago neisser and weene 1962 suggested that human learners tended to prefer the logically simplest category consistent with their observations, but their suggestion was not met with enthusiasm in the learning literature. According to rulex, people learn to classify objects by forming simple logical rules and remembering occasional exceptions to those rules. Palmeri, and stephen c, mckinley the authors propose a ruleplusexception model rulex of classification learning. Dominowski and wetherick 1976 have taken a more direct approach toward examining. Different types of contingency positive and negative. The second main topic of interest in the present study was the relationship between the two abilities postulated by sternberg. Theoreticalnote acatalogofbooleanconcepts jacobfeldman department of psychology, center for cognitive science, rutgers university, busch campus, new brunswick, nj 08903, usa. It predicts that finding an angular letter in a field of round letters would be easier because the distractors have fewer. Minimization of boolean complexity in human concept. Analysis of responses to certain categories of questions was undertaken.
The experimental material was that developed by neisser and weene, with concepts taken from their level ii. Ruleplusexception model of classification learning robert m. Research on measures of conceptual complexity has in large part focused on explaining why learning these concepts is increasingly dif. They also found that ease of learning was directly related to simplicity so defined. Differences in conceptrule difficulty have been interpreted in various ways. Structure and substance in arti cialphonology learning elliott moreton joe pater uncchapel hill umassamherst version 4. At the time these results were seen as very supportive of dualmemory models although alternative interpretations. In psychological experiments subjective complexity is measured in terms of the rate and accuracy of learning an articial category dened by some usually visual features such as color, size, shape, and so on.
Conant and trabasso 1964 and neisser and weene 1962 reported evidence related to the first two of these questions. Of particular importance for this latter project was a sequence of six concepts that are increasingly dif. The acquisition of boolean concepts trends in cognitive. Absolute versus relative class conceptual behavior in squirrel. The following notation system is used to represent the structure of concepts. Consequently to these presuppositions neisser claims conceptualisation to be. Moreover, the idea may have also failed to catch on because the fundamental mathematical ideas. Memory load and conceptrule difficulty sciencedirect. Sizable general positive intra and interrule transfer effects were observed. In rule learning tasks, however, the order given above has been replicated on at least a dozen different occasions. This idea, when it had been proposed in slightly different forms by both neisser and weene 1962 and haygood 1963, had not met with acceptance in the psychological literature.
A read is counted each time someone views a publication summary such as the title, abstract, and list of authors, clicks on a figure, or views or downloads the fulltext. Neisser and weene 1962, for example, proposed a system of logical complexity for the psychological processes required by different rules. One might ask whether structural complexity makes a difference in how well concepts are retained. Classic psychological studies showed that such concepts differed in how difficult they were to learn, but did not explain the source of these differences. Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders 4th ed. Mental models of boolean concepts university of pennsylvania. Classification in welldefined and illdefined categories.
Simplicity and complexity in human concept learning. Absolute versus relative class conceptual behavior in. Theories based on formal rules of inference cannot explain the phenomenon, but merely assume post hoc that rules for conjunction are easier to. For example, disjunction problems generally are more difficult than conjunction problems. They assumed that the operations of negation, conjunction, and disjunction, were primitive, and analyzed the relative complexity of other sorts of boolean concepts in terms of them. Neisser and weene 1962 and, separately, haygood 1963 had proposed that the known difficulty ordering of bivariate concepts could be explained in terms of the length of the logical formulas required to express them. More recent models of human concept learning often have a very different. Coping with novelty and automatization of information. The effects were traceable to the acquisition by ss of a simple. Consider haygood and bournes 1965 example of an inclusivedisjunctive concept. Problems of functional properties individuals can carry out the task of categorising instances of a concept without attempting to formulate its minimal description. Simplicity and complexity in human concept learning jacob feldman dept. Were upgrading the acm dl, and would like your input.
This experiment compares times to find a z in a column of round letters o, s, q vs. Ulrich neisser 1964 used a computer model of pattern recognition selfridge 1959 to direct his. The models are developed by synthesizing mentalarchitecture, randomwalk, and decisionbound approaches. For example, exclusiveor requires more symbols to ex. Learning and utilization of conjunctive and disjunctive classification.
The easy group of connectives negative implication, negative disjunction, and conjunction had the. They also found that ease of learning was directly. Pdf hierarchies in concept attainmen in the selection. Neisser and weene 1962 extended the early treatment of boolean concepts. Turner 1967 suggested that four logical operations. In taxonomies, categories are organised by the type relation, which specifies that one category is a type or kind of another. Because of the relative inability of young children to solve logical problems e.
Level i concepts were the simplest and formed the components of level 2 concepts. Bilinguals understanding of logical connectives in english. Unless an experimental design demands the use of a higher level operation, it may be possible to interpret the results in terms of a lower level one. Gottwald yale university the attainment of three concepts was studied with all irrelevant attributes. Hierarchies in concept attainmen in the selection mode. Learning and transfer in hierarchically structured concept.
Problems of functional properties individuals can carry out the task of categorizing instances of a concept without attempting to formulate its minimal description. Pdf effect of number of irrelevant dimensions with ten. David bourget western ontario david chalmers anu, nyu area editors. For example, are biconditional concepts more difficult to retain than structurallysimple conjunctive concepts. The a and b stimuli were nonsense syllables, and the c stimuli were sets of short or long lines. In psycholog ical experiments subjective complexity is. We are testing a new system for linking publications to authors. Rule differences, practice, and verbal solutions using a. Pdf hierarchies in concept attainmen in the selection mode. In forms 1 and 2, the sesotho groups performed better than the english groups, although both groups performed poorly.
In psychological experiments subjective complexity is measured in terms of the rate and accuracy of learning an arti. Sound change structural typology elliott moreton1 university of north carolina, chapel hill address for correspondence about this talk. The outcome was that the push provided by neisser and weene led to deeper analyses and. Bilinguals understanding of logical connectives in. Request pdf on researchgate an inference model for conceptual rule. The simplicity principle in perception and cognition ncbi nih. One of the unsolved problems in the field of human concept learning concerns the factors that determine the subjective difficulty of concepts. Alternatively, you can download the file locally and open with any standalone pdf reader. Logicalrule models of classification response times. This relationship is of considerable importance with respect to the question, whether coping with novelty and automatization of information processing account for independent aspects of intelligence.
Hierarchies in concept attainmen in the selection mode with exemplar and nonexemplar start cards. Evolution of intelligence 455 animals responses to its enviroment. Given the concepts that neisser and weene postulate as primitive, the three. In forms 1 and 2, the sesotho groups performed better. If you identify any major omissions or other inaccuracies in the publication list, please let us know. Later work by neisser and weene 1962 developed a systematic hierarchy of conceptrule difficulty levels based on both a priori logical considerations and trials to criterion data. Developmental trends in the use of logical connectives.
Two threemember classes were formed by training ab and bc using a conditional discrimination procedure. Concepts 15 an induction, when we make an analogy, when we understand sentences containing a lexeme expressing the concept of xin brief, when we rely on what are commonly called our higher cognitive competences or capac. Boolean relations, such as and, or, and not, are a fundamental way to create new concepts out of old. In retrospect this was probably due to the fact that studies at the time were limited almost exclusively to the families 21 and 22, where this pattern is not yet. Diagnostic and statistic manual of mental disorders. An examination of the e ects of featural complexity on phonological learning, and the relation to nonlinguistic pattern learning e.
In one attempt to be specific about simplicity, neisser and weene 1962 posited some basic logical operations i. The theory expects this difference and indeed predicts an extended order of rule difficulty for all primary bidimensional rules and their complements bourne, 1974. Strictly speaking, it is accepted that such an entity cannot be considered apart from an animals biological. We formalize and provide tests of a set of logicalrule models for predicting perceptual classification response times rts and choice probabilities. Three distinct groupings of difficulty were apparent. In the conanttrabasso experiment, the subjects were required to discover the solution to structurally equivalent conjunctive and disjunctive problems under a seleetion paradigm. Recent theories have reinvigorated the field with explanations ranging from the complexity of minimal descriptions of a concept to the. One reason for this surprising neglect is the historical prominence of the dichotomy between conjunctive. Rules and exemplars in categorization, identification, and. Instances were presented one by one on a typewritten sheet, on which the s was required to write an hypothesis after the presentation of each instance.
606 291 971 680 249 736 176 742 1338 310 596 1241 722 1106 1448 1064 810 1172 858 340 289 670 1346 266 968 157 454 1403 543 217 612 1007